In an electrifying episode of “America’s Got Talent” (AGT) 2025, 13-year-old Evelyn Aronte from Phoenix, Arizona, captivated both the audience and judges with her soulful rendition of “Defying Gravity” from the musical “Wicked.” Evelyn, who has dreamt of performing on Broadway since childhood, showcased not only her vocal talent but also her passion for musical theater, which she aspires to make her career.

As she stepped onto the stage, Evelyn radiated enthusiasm, declaring her lifelong ambition to become a superstar who brings joy to others through her performances. Her choice of song, a powerful anthem about self-discovery and breaking free from constraints, resonated deeply, setting the tone for a memorable audition.

Evelyn’s performance enchanted the audience, leading to a fervent response from the judges. While some praised her potential, others offered constructive criticism. Judge Simon Cowell expressed his mixed feelings about the song choice, acknowledging the courage it takes to perform such a well-known piece. He highlighted Evelyn’s ambition, suggesting that despite the challenges ahead, she should be encouraged to pursue her dreams.

The judges’ reactions were varied but ultimately supportive. Two judges voted in favor of her advancement, recognizing that at just 13 years old, Evelyn has significant room for growth. They commended her for her vocal ability and stage presence, with one judge noting that her voice would only improve as she matures. However, one judge remained cautious, offering a “no” vote while acknowledging her talent.

Despite the mixed reviews, Evelyn secured enough yes votes to progress, demonstrating resilience and determination. The emotional weight of her performance and the judges’ feedback highlighted the competitive nature of AGT, where not only talent but also the right song choice can make or break an audition.

As the episode concluded, the excitement surrounding Evelyn’s journey was palpable, leaving viewers eager to follow her progress on the show. Her story is a testament to the young artists who dream of making it big in the world of musical theater, reminding us all that the path to success is often paved with both triumphs and challenges. Evelyn Aronte’s audition marks just the beginning of what promises to be a remarkable journey in her pursuit of Broadway stardom.